Last Sunset
Just as the
Alphans look into the possibility of settling on a planet called Ariel, an
alien probe attaches itself to an Eagle and once esconsed in the base suddenly
releases what appears to be gas but turns out to be air. In record time this
spreads initiating a speedy (and well realised) terraforming that gives the Moon a blue sky, a Sun
and fresh air. It doesn’t take long before people start messing around in
swimsuits. Its rare for an episode to contain so much that is incredulous yet
to centre around a narrative that proves to be reasonably gritty for the
series. The new look lunar landscape turns out to be something of a convenience
for the show to undertake a `main characters stranded` episode which it does
rather well.
Thus when
Helena, Paul, Sandra and Alan end up stranded in the faux desert with no
supplies, their Eagle near invisible half buried in desert terrain the episode
gets good. Thanks to director Charles Crichton’s eye for an interesting shot
and writer Christopher Penfold’s determination to wring a lot from this
scenario the results are very convincing. Even though its filmed on a studio
set you get a real sense of a difficult outdoors location while all four actors
seem to relish the opportunity to get more than usual to do. Prentis Hancock
has the best role though as an increasingly desperate Paul goes rogue then eats
some fungus he finds outside that looks rather like mushrooms. Before you know
it he is talking like the leader of a new planet and Prentis Hancock gives it
his wild eyed all. Oh and Alan has a fight but then he does tend to do that
every episode!
The dust and heat plus the heavy metal of the damaged Eagle ship are so convincingly realised while the methods the stranded crew use at different points rely for a change on their ingenuity rather than any high tech solutions. Helena in particular looks lost without her equipment! All this contributes to a tense and intriguing survivalist drama.
It’s a pity then that the last few minutes drop the ball. Having dazzled with such creative direction and lovely images till now, it is a shame the fight sequences near the end betray extensive use of stunt people in wigs! On the writing side having admirably smoothed the corners of what could have been a more awkward storyline, Penfold concludes the episode with a message from the aliens rather than leaving their motives obscure. It just spoils the mood a little though the last Sunset from which the episode takes its title is a strong way to finish an interesting and mostly very well assembled story.
The dust and heat plus the heavy metal of the damaged Eagle ship are so convincingly realised while the methods the stranded crew use at different points rely for a change on their ingenuity rather than any high tech solutions. Helena in particular looks lost without her equipment! All this contributes to a tense and intriguing survivalist drama.
It’s a pity then that the last few minutes drop the ball. Having dazzled with such creative direction and lovely images till now, it is a shame the fight sequences near the end betray extensive use of stunt people in wigs! On the writing side having admirably smoothed the corners of what could have been a more awkward storyline, Penfold concludes the episode with a message from the aliens rather than leaving their motives obscure. It just spoils the mood a little though the last Sunset from which the episode takes its title is a strong way to finish an interesting and mostly very well assembled story.
Voyager's Return
A thoughtful
and different take on the subject of science versus responsibility sees an
earth probe from 1985 called Voyager approach Alpha. Launched to discover new
life and gather data it’s flaw was the Quellor Drive, designed to facilitate
such a lengthy mission but possessing a side effect that can destroy planets.
Now with a limited time period left, the Alphans try to think of a way to
extract the valuable information it contains. It’s an odd episode because while
being well presented and acted, the plot is just a little too convenient. Turns
out that Professor Ernst Quellor himself is on the base albeit working under a
pseudonym. Another handy story coincidence is that his research assistant
Haines just happens to be someone whose parents were killed by the effects of
this drive. Even if you can swallow these contrivances it begs the question as
to why there was never an investigation into the whole thing (this is not the
only Voyager with the drive we later learn) and work on it suspended. Or indeed
how its presumably well known inventor managed to bag a post on Alpha without
anyone at all recognising him.
Then just when Quellor’s
made his breakthrough in terms of getting the necessary information, Haines
figures out who the professor really is- even though he is clearly in earshot
when a dialogue between Queller and Victor takes place which makes that
obvious. Later on still some powerful aliens turn up to dispense justice on the
whole of Earth as the drive wiped out two planets worth of their people. While
all this stacks up you wonder why they haven’t done anything till now and why
when the thing is in range they don’t just fire. Trouble is the story makes the
nature of this drive so vague and variable that it might just as soon be called
the Maguffin Drive. Some of the equipment Queller uses to try and interfere
with Voyager’s systems doesn’t convince either being basically a collection of
flashing lights.
While such
things might sink a lesser episode, there is still much to enjoy including some
proper professional differences between the leading crew over what to do (and
Carter doens’t threaten to lamp anyone for a change!), a really tense final
sequence and some excellent on screen effects although the director clearly
forgot to ask anyone to react to them. There’s also a sympathetic performance from
Jeremy Kemp who overcomes having to talk in a very theatrical German accent to
put across Queller’s feelings of guilt over what happened and by the end
becomes a more sympathetic character than you’d imagine. The idea is great but
the realisation contains just too many coincidences to be believed,
No comments:
Post a Comment